Humility vs Arrogance – assessing in the hiring process

Published on September 23, 2017

Written / Hosted by:

Recently I interviewed a rookie candidate, just graduated, with no industry experience. He told me that he would be awesome at the job, would be the best, he would be great at anything he put his hand to. I have to say, his confidence was impressive and he certainly said all the right things of how he would achieve this, but what he lacked was humility .

Not only in sales, but across the board, I think humility is highly linked to emotional intelligence and this is something which is incredibly hard to teach (often it is innate). Often a lack of humility can also lead to arrogance which is a trait which most people don’t warm to very well (I am sure you will agree). When hiring your team I think it is important to assess these traits, not only for team or culture fit but also in relation to your customers and what personalities they like to deal with.

So how do we assess this at interview? I have collated some questions which I think will allow you to tease out humility vs arrogance to help you build the best team you can!

  1. Do you ever feel like you are missing a certain skill?

    The short answer you want to hear here is yes. You want the candidate to tell you that actually there is a particular skill they think they are missing and what they are doing to improve this i.e. are they doing training, are they taking a course in their own time etc? If the candidate struggles to tell you what they are doing for development or even says a flat no, more often than not it is due to a lack of humility and they simply don’t identify any areas of improvement.

  2. Can you tell me the last time you made a mistake and how did you handle that?

    You want to hear that they firstly owned up to the mistake, apologised to people involved and tried to do everything they could to resolve the problem. Many answers I have received to this question involve telling their manager and hoping the manager would sort out the issue; obviously this isn’t ideal either. Someone who has humility would make him/herself accountable and (maybe with the assistance of their manager) and aim to rectify the problem as soon as possible with as few issues as possible for everyone involved.

  3. Describe the type of relationships you have with your colleagues.

    Someone who builds long lasting and professional relationships with their colleagues is a sign of a good employee and often someone who has humility. Sometimes I will go further into this question and ask How would the others in your team describe you? This will give you further insight into the candidate’s professional relationships and their daily attitude to work.

Hopefully these questions are helpful in your next hiring process and help you to find the next member of your team.

Humility (noun) – The quality of having a modest view of one’s importance.

From our blog

View our blogs and webinar recordings for insights into recruitment in the healthcare industry, company culture and to hear from senior leaders in the healthcare industry on what they are doing in their organisations, along with tips on landing your dream job.

By Shazamme System User July 6, 2026
Land more interviews in healthcare, pharma, and medical device roles. PPD Search shares resume, voicemail, and tailoring tips to help you stand out. Read on.
By Elizabeth Pettit July 6, 2026
When asked in an interview, ‘What’s your motivation to leave your current role?’ Here's the most appropriate answers to give, as shared by PPD Search.
By Elizabeth Pettit July 6, 2026
These common interview mistakes are many of the reasons why recruiters reject candidates. Get informed with these insights from PPD Search.
By Elizabeth Pettit July 6, 2026
Discover how to write a pharmaceutical resume with formatting and healthcare resume tips from PPD Search.
By Elizabeth Pettit March 19, 2026
Compare pharmaceutical recruitment agencies in Australia and choose the best agency for your next role through specialist pharmaceutical jobs support.
By Elizabeth Pettit March 19, 2026
The most senior healthcare executive roles rarely appear on job boards. They are filled through direct approaches, referrals and the kind of long-standing employer relationships that specialist search firms spend years building. If you are a senior leader looking to make a considered career move in healthcare, understanding how to engage productively with an executive search firm is as important as having the right experience on paper.  What Executive Search Firms Actually Do Unlike contingency recruiters who post roles and respond to applications, executive search firms work on retained or exclusive briefs from organisations seeking to fill specific leadership positions. They identify and approach candidates directly, often targeting people who are not actively looking but who represent a strong fit for the organisation's strategic needs. For candidates, this means that a relationship with a firm conducting healthcare executive search is not transactional. The firm is not simply matching your CV to a vacancy. They are assessing whether your experience, leadership style and career trajectory align with the types of organisations they represent and the roles they are likely to be briefed on. That assessment happens over time, through conversation, and it starts well before any specific opportunity is in play. How to Position Yourself Before a Role Comes to Market The executives who move most effectively through the senior market are those who invest in their professional profile before they need to. That means being clear on what you want from your next role, being able to articulate your leadership philosophy and commercial impact, and ensuring that your visible presence in the industry reflects your actual calibre. When you engage with executive search firms in healthcare management, come prepared. Know your key achievements in quantifiable terms. Understand the kinds of organisations you want to lead and why. Be honest about what you are not looking for. A search consultant who understands your full picture is far better placed to advocate for you when the right opportunity arises. You can find practical guidance on how to present yourself effectively at a senior level through the candidate tips section of the PPD Search website, which covers everything from how to approach senior interviews to how to frame a career transition. The Value of a Long-Term Relationship Over a Transactional One One of the most common mistakes senior candidates make is reaching out to a search firm only when they are actively looking. By that point, the consultant has no context for who you are, no feel for your leadership style and no established basis for trust. The relationship starts from zero at exactly the moment you need it to count. The top healthcare executive recruiting firms operate on the basis of long-term relationships with both candidates and clients. They know who is likely to be right for what before the brief arrives. Building that relationship early, and maintaining it even when you are settled and not looking, is what puts you in position when the right role comes up. At PPD Search, executive candidates are supported through every stage of their leadership journey, not just at the point of active search. That ongoing engagement is what allows us to make introductions quickly and with confidence when the right brief lands. What to Expect from a Quality Search Process If a search firm approaches you about a specific healthcare executive job, the process will typically involve an initial conversation to assess fit, a more structured interview with the search consultant, and then, if there is alignment, an introduction to the client organisation. At every stage, a quality firm will give you honest feedback, share what they know about the organisation's culture and leadership expectations, and help you prepare effectively. What you should not experience is being submitted to a role without a briefing, being kept in the dark about where you sit in the process, or receiving vague feedback that tells you nothing useful. If that is happening, it reflects the quality of the firm, not the quality of your candidacy. How PPD Search Approaches Executive Healthcare Recruitment PPD Search works exclusively within pharmaceutical, medical device, diagnostics and life sciences. Our values reflect a commitment to depth over volume: fewer searches, better outcomes and a genuine understanding of the commercial and clinical environments our clients operate within. We work with Boards, CEOs and HR leaders across Australia to fill senior leadership positions, and we maintain active relationships with experienced executives at every stage of their careers. Our approach to healthcare executive search is built on the principle that the best placements come from the best relationships, not the fastest turnarounds. Ready to Have a Conversation? Whether you are actively considering a move or simply want to understand how your experience maps to the current senior market, we are glad to have that conversation. Get in touch with the PPD Search team to discuss your career position and where the opportunities in healthcare executive jobs are heading.
Show More